Tracker
9 of 21 tasks done. This page is built from the live task board.
Landed results
- #18 negative QT45: 0.24%/0.17% per 72 d vs half-life ~117 d gives net 0.65 per 72 d; synthesis must rise ~210x (~970x for perfect copies). Attwater 2025: short templates 1.11-1.46 per cycle, 29-nt ribozyme fragment up to 1.26, but the replicase is resupplied, never copied.
- #5 negative Under sealed rule v1 (scorer unchanged, planted 28/28) no route is continuous: 0/22 hand-offs continuous; 9 hard-fail, 12 blocked by missing steps, 1 unverified pass (cyanosulfidic C3->C4). Hard fails: cyano 5, ice 2, pond 2, vent 0 (5/6 vent steps missing); top gaps S5 replication missing everywhere, scenario-made purines/activated substrates (F4/F6), formamide hand-offs (F3). map.json feeds the site.
- #17 data Warm pond = no nucleotide source -> Simonis 2026 (abstract only: Seltun water destroys ~90% of A10/U10 in 4 cycles) -> Caimi 2025 (36% AUGC oligomers, 0.1% 10-mer, pH 11, 23 C, commercial cNMPs). 0/4 hand-offs continuous: entry F4, P0->P1 F6, P1->P2 F4 (no G/C) + F6.
- #4 data Cyanosulfidic (10 steps), alkaline vent (6), warm pond (5) and ice-RNA (5) encoded from 9 full texts + 2 abstracts; every number cites its DOI and location, unknowns kept as null. Only 2 of 26 steps have a yield from unpurified inputs (Ritson 2012 C1, Altair 2025 V1); 10 are missing or unread (Powner 2009 paywalled).
- #2 negative On published QT45 numbers (0.24%/0.17% full-length yield per 72 d; t1/2 117 d) a strand population shrinks: lambda=0.43 per (+)->(-)->(+) cycle, break-even needs ~53% yield per 72 d (262x more), and lambda<1 for any half-life under ~68 y. The second-hand '0.02%' is the per-ribozyme yield (0.024%); per template it is 0.24%.
- #20 data Already covered: the hashed rule lists thermophoresis with a factor <=1000 in vent_chimney/porous_rock settings, which matches Matreux 2024's 'up to three orders of magnitude'. Note: its 10^5 yield gain came from selective TMP enrichment downstream, which the rule scores as a yield, not a process; no change needed.
- #14 mixed Every citation in fable_plan, content.json and news.json resolves to a real DOI, but 5 claims and 2 attributions were wrong and are fixed: QT45 yield ~0.2% not 0.02%; exponential replication of short RNAs shown (Attwater 2025); Bennu racemic wording; magnetite ee 60% max / 35% mean; assembly-theory authors. News: 19 items, all verified with DOI links (7 corrected, 12 added).
- #1 data docs/PAPERS.csv has 62 papers, all resolved by DOI; 32 had claims checked against abstract or full text, 30 metadata only. Wet-dry: Caimi 2025 polymerises cyclic nucleotides without activators (0.1% reach 10-mers); lipid world: 2 rows of 2026 evidence, inheritance not shown.
- #3 tool Compatibility rule v1 sealed in docs/prereg/compatibility_rule.md (sha256 bfa572ed...) before any pathway was scored: 14 named processes, 9 hard fails, 3 warnings. Scorer flags the planted pH2->pH10 same-pot hand-off (F1 only) and gets 28/28 planted cases right (16/16 violations, 12/12 compliant twins clean).
All tasks
M1 · Latest research sweep
- #1 2023-2026 paper ledger, DOI-verified done
- #2 QT45 numbers from the paper and deposit done
M2 · Pathway map
- #3 Hash the step-compatibility rule done
- #4 Encode pathways as step tables done
- #17 Pond (wet-dry) step table done
- #18 Net replication per cycle from Attwater 2025 done
- #20 Rule on thermophoretic purification in the compatibility rule done
- #5 Score all pathways done
M3 · Bench published claims
- #6 RAF null test open
- #7 Assembly index vs a size-only null in progress
- #15 Our own hypotheses (H track) open
- #10 LUCA robustness scan open
M4 · Planted controls
- #8 Planted autocatalytic core recovery in progress
- #9 Simulated-tree LUCA recovery in progress
M5 · Sealed predictions
- #11 Bennu abundance prediction open
- #12 QT45 double-mutant prediction open
- #19 Seal purine:pyrimidine vs ammonia prediction for returned samples open
M6 · Red team
- #14 Citation audit done
- #21 Red-team the pathway-map encoding open
- #16 Red-team the citation audit and news page open
- #13 Independent rerun of the bench open