Pathway map
The route from geochemistry to evolving life, one step per row. A step counts as shown only if it works under conditions the previous step could provide.
The steps
| Step | Best evidence | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Feedstocks (HCN, formaldehyde, phosphate, sulfides) in a stated setting | Several settings proposed; each supplies a different subset. | Partial |
| Amino acids and nucleobases | Made in many routes; 33 amino acids and all five nucleobases in Bennu (2025); all five nucleobases in Ryugu (2026). | Met |
| Ribose and nucleotides | Ribose found in Bennu, deoxyribose not (Furukawa et al. 2025); pyrimidine nucleotides made by a route that needs ordered steps (Powner et al. 2009). | Partial |
| Activation (energy-carrying building blocks) | Thioester routes in water at neutral pH (Singh et al. 2025). | Partial |
| Polymers long enough to fold | Shown with purified inputs. Wet-dry cycling gives short mixed RNA chains without activators, 0.1% reaching 10 letters (Caimi et al. 2025); continuity unscored. | Partial |
| Template copying | QT45 copies itself and its complement in ice at about 0.2% yield in 72 days (2026). | Partial |
| Exponential self-replication | Short RNA duplexes, including a ribozyme fragment, replicated exponentially from supplied triplets under freeze-thaw cycles (Attwater et al. 2025); never a whole replicator from scenario feedstocks. | Not met |
| Compartments that grow and divide with their contents | Peptide sequence sets vesicle growth rate (Baba et al. 2026); membranes formed without a parent membrane, using enzymes (Khanal et al. 2026). Growth and division coupled to contents not shown. | Partial |
| Darwinian evolution | RNA-catalysed evolution of a catalytic RNA (Papastavrou, Horning & Joyce, PNAS 2024), not open-ended. | Not met |
These statuses come from the literature. Our own scoring, under a compatibility rule hashed in advance, replaces them as the step tables land (tracker tasks #3-#5).
Scenarios
Alkaline hydrothermal vents
Explains: a natural energy source (pH gradients) and CO2 reduction to formate and acetate.
Cannot yet: anything beyond two-carbon products; nucleotides.
Surface ponds with wet-dry cycles
Explains: concentration and joining of nucleotides by drying, without added activators.
Cannot yet: chains stay short as breakdown balances growth; some natural spring waters destroy RNA.
Cyanosulfidic surface chemistry
Explains: common origins for nucleotide, amino acid and lipid precursors under UV light.
Cannot yet: needs reagents delivered in a set order.
Ice (eutectic freezing)
Explains: concentrates RNA and slows breakdown; QT45 works here.
Cannot yet: where the activated triplets come from.