| RNA world | Small polymerase ribozymes are common in sequence space and can run a closed copying cycle. | For: QT45 (Gianni, Holliger et al., Science 2026), a 45-nucleotide ribozyme, made a copy of itself and of its complementary strand from triplet building blocks in mildly alkaline ice, at about 0.2% yield in 72 days. A larger polymerase ribozyme replicated short double-stranded RNAs exponentially, including a fragment of itself, under pH and freeze-thaw cycles (Attwater et al., Nature Chemistry 2025). Against: the triplets are pre-activated and supplied by the experimenters, and no ribozyme has yet replicated its whole self exponentially. | Partial |
|---|
| Alkaline vents / metabolism firstLane, Russell | Natural pH gradients across iron-sulfur barriers drive CO2 reduction well past formate. | Formate depends on the pH gradient (Hudson et al., PNAS 2020); micromolar formic and acetic acid across iron-sulfide walls (Altair et al., JACS 2025). Nothing beyond two-carbon products yet. | Strained |
|---|
| Warm ponds / wet-dry cyclingDeamer, Damer | Repeated drying makes long, copyable polymers faster than water breaks them. | For: wet-dry cycling joins cyclic nucleotides of all four bases into chains without added activators, up to about 70% yield for G (Caimi et al., ACS Central Science 2025). Against: the chains are short (0.1% reach 10 letters) as growth and breakdown balance, and water from one Icelandic hot spring destroyed about 90% of 10-letter RNAs in four cycles (Šimonis et al., Astrobiology 2026). | Partial |
|---|
| Cyanosulfidic chemistrySutherland | One UV-lit surface setting supplies nucleotide, amino acid and lipid precursors without incompatible steps. | Strong step by step: precursors of nucleotides, amino acids and lipids from one chemistry (Patel et al. 2015). On our pathway map its sugars come out trapped as oxazolidinones, so the first hand-off breaks, and 8 of its 9 hand-offs are unexplained. | Strained |
|---|
| Peptide-RNA co-evolutionPowner and others | Amino acids attach to RNA in a selective way without enzymes, a first step toward coding. | Thioester-driven aminoacylation of RNA in water, favoured over random peptide bonding (Singh, Powner et al., Nature 2025). Coding itself is unexplained. | Partial |
|---|
| Autocatalytic sets (RAF)Hordijk, Steel, Xavier | Self-sustaining reaction sets in real metabolism are more than an artefact of network size. | A maxRAF of 1,335 reactions, a quarter of an ancient anaerobic network, once cofactors are in the food set (Xavier et al., Proc R Soc B 2020). Never tested against randomised networks. | Untested |
|---|
| Assembly theoryCronin, Walker | Molecules with assembly index above about 15, in many copies, occur only with life. | Mineral units score up to 21 (Hazen et al., J R Soc Interface 2024); assembly index argued to be a compression measure (Uthamacumaran et al., npj Syst Biol Appl 2024; Abrahão et al., PLOS Complex Systems 2024; Ozelim et al., npj Complexity 2026). Proponents reply that Hazen's values are theoretical (Walker et al., J R Soc Interface 2024) and that the index differs from compression (Kempes et al., npj Complexity 2025). | Contested |
|---|
| Homochirality | A physical process biases one handedness strongly enough to be amplified. | Bennu's measurable chiral amino acids are racemic, like Ryugu's, which counts against delivery from space (Glavin et al., Nature Astronomy 2025). A magnetite spin route (Ozturk et al., Science Advances 2023) gives about 60% excess at best and about 35% on average after recrystallisation; above about 25%, one more crystallisation gives pure crystals. | Strained |
|---|
| Lipid worldLancet, Segré, Deamer | Compartments can grow, divide and pass on their make-up before any genetic polymer exists. | Peptide sequences change how fast fatty-acid vesicles grow (Baba et al., Communications Chemistry 2026); bilayers form from scratch without a parent membrane, but with enzymes (Khanal et al., Nature Communications 2026). Inheritance of composition is not yet shown. | Untested |
|---|