Open Citizen ScienceOpen Origins

2024-02-21 · Paper · J. R. Soc. Interface 21:20230632

Molecular assembly indices of mineral heteropolyanions (Hazen et al.)

Hazen, Burns, Cleaves, Downs, Krivovichev, Wong

Some mineral building units score above the assembly-index threshold proposed for life.

Assembly theory says molecules needing 15 or more joining steps, found in many copies, are a sign of life. This team calculated the score for clusters of atoms that form in water and build some minerals. The most complex, in the rare minerals ewingite and ilmajokite, scored 21, so a high score alone cannot mean life.

Heteropolyanions range from assembly index 2 (H2CO3, Si(OH)4) to 21 (ewingite, ilmajokite). Reply by Walker, Mathis, Marshall and Cronin (J. R. Soc. Interface 21:20240367, 2024): the ~15 threshold comes from experimentally measured covalent organic molecules, while these indices are theoretical, from crystal structures of charged units not isolable in solution. Counter-reply: Hazen et al., 21:20240622.

What we do with it

A direct challenge to assembly index as a biosignature; task #7 tests it against a size-only classifier. Planned

Read the original. Source checked against the original.

All news