2025-08-27 · Paper · Astronomy & Astrophysics 700:A284
Insufficient evidence for DMS and DMDS in the atmosphere of K2-18 b (Luque et al.)
No statistically significant detection of DMS or DMDS when all JWST data on K2-18 b are analysed together.
A 2025 claim said JWST had seen a gas on the planet K2-18 b that on Earth comes only from life. This team analysed all three JWST instruments' data together, using several processing pipelines and two retrieval codes. The evidence for the gas was not significant, and other simple molecules fit the data as well.
Joint 0.6-12 µm NIRISS, NIRSpec and MIRI analysis with three reductions and two retrieval codes. No statistically significant evidence for DMS or DMDS; methyl-bearing molecules such as ethane fit as well. With the best-fitting DMS/DMDS model, about 25 more MIRI transits are needed for a 3-sigma rejection of a flat line. arXiv:2505.13407.
What we do with it
A reminder of how biosignature claims fail under proper alternatives. Off the origin-of-life path, so no test planned. context
Read the original. Source checked against the original.