Each route, step by step
- Yield published from the setting's own inputs
- Yield published, but only from purified or bought inputs
- No published step known to us
- Published, but we could not open the full text
- Hand-off breaks a hard rule
- Hand-off leads to or from a missing step
- No rule broken, but some checks lack numbers
No route runs from raw materials to a self-copying molecule
S1Small sugars
S2Nucleotides
S3RNA chains
S4Template copying
S5Sustained replication
Cyanosulfidic
10 steps · 8 of 9 hand-offs unexplained
S1 · Small sugars
Raw materials of the setting
Passes, not fully checkable
Sugars from cyanide, trappedC1 · S1
HCN -> glycolaldehyde and glyceraldehyde (trapped as cyanate oxazolidinones), Cu(I) photoredox
oxazolidinone 13 (from glycolaldehyde) ~15% on average per 4 HCN; 14 (from glyceraldehyde) 1-5%; ~30% of HCN lost to a black polymer
Yield from the setting's own inputs. Source
First break. F4 input source
2-thiooxazoleC2 · S1
glycolaldehyde + thiocyanic acid -> 2-thiooxazole
85% (isolated)
Yield only from purified inputs. Source
F4 input source
Pentose thionesC3 · S1
2-thiooxazole + glyceraldehyde -> pentose oxazolidinone thiones (1a)
up to 74% thione 1a in 24 h (70% ribo+arabino 1:1, 30% lyxo/xylo)
Yield only from purified inputs. Source
S2 · Nucleotides
Passes, not fully checkable
AminooxazolinesC4 · S2
thione 1a + cyanoacetylene + ammonia -> arabino- and ribo-aminooxazoline (10a)
15-23% 10a per pass from cyanovinyl thione 1b with NH4Cl 1 M at pH 8.5-10.5; 45% arabino + 33% ribo over two cyanovinylation/ammonolysis cycles at pH 10.5
Yield only from purified inputs. Source
Leads to or from a missing step
AnhydrocytidineC5 · S2
arabino-aminooxazoline + cyanoacetylene -> 2,2'-anhydrocytidine
published (Powner 2009) but full text paywalled; not read
Published, full text not read. Source
F3 solvent, F6 purified hand-off
Cytidine cyclic phosphateC6 · S2
anhydrocytidine + phosphate + urea in formamide -> cytidine-2',3'-cyclic phosphate
44% (co-phosphorylated with 8,2'-anhydro-adenosine, 34%); formamide, 100 C, 72 h
Yield only from purified inputs. Source
F3 solvent
Uridine by UV lightC7 · S2
UV: cytidine-2',3'-cyclic phosphate -> uridine-2',3'-cyclic phosphate (partial)
published (Powner 2009, Fig. 5) but full text paywalled; not read
Published, full text not read. Source
S3 · RNA chains
F4 input source, F6 purified hand-off
Short RNA chainsC8 · S3
wet-dry polymerisation of 2',3'-cyclic nucleotides (A, U, G, C) -> RNA oligomers
AUGC at pH 11: Y = 36% into oligomers; 6% 4-mer, 0.1% 10-mer (10 cycles)
Yield only from purified inputs. Source
S4 · Template copying
Leads to or from a missing step
Template copyingC9 · S4
template-directed copying of oligomers under the same conditions
no published step known to us
No published step.
S5 · Sustained replication
Leads to or from a missing step
Sustained replicationC10 · S5
sustained replication of a replicator made from these oligomers
no published step known to us
No published step.
Alkaline vent
6 steps · 5 of 5 hand-offs unexplained
S1 · Small sugars
Raw materials of the setting
Passes, not fully checkable
Formate and acetateV1 · S1
CO2 + H2 -> formate + acetate across Ni-FeS under pH and thermal gradients
formic acid 735.9 uM, acetic acid 11.15 uM after 18 h (ocean 6 C pH 5.7 / vent 75 C pH 11, Ni-FeS)
Yield from the setting's own inputs. Source
First break. Leads to or from a missing step
Small sugarsV2 · S1
formate/acetate -> C2-C3 sugars or aldehydes under vent conditions
no published step known to us
No published step.
S2 · Nucleotides
Leads to or from a missing step
NucleotidesV3 · S2
-> nucleobases and ribonucleotides under vent conditions
no published step known to us
No published step.
S3 · RNA chains
Leads to or from a missing step
RNA chainsV4 · S3
nucleotide polymerisation in vent pores
no published step known to us
No published step.
S4 · Template copying
Leads to or from a missing step
Template copyingV5 · S4
template copying
no published step known to us
No published step.
S5 · Sustained replication
Leads to or from a missing step
Sustained replicationV6 · S5
sustained replication
no published step known to us
No published step.
Warm pond
5 steps · 4 of 4 hand-offs unexplained
S1 · Small sugars
Not part of this route
S2 · Nucleotides
Raw materials of the setting
First break. F4 input source
NucleotidesP0 · S2
nucleotide synthesis in the pond
no published step known to us
No published step.
F6 purified hand-off
Cyclic nucleotidesP1 · S2
wet-dry cycling of 5'-AMP / 5'-UMP in hot-spring water -> cyclic mononucleotides, U dimers
abstract reports synthesis of cyclic mononucleotides and U dimers; no yield in abstract; full text not opened
Published, full text not read. Source
S3 · RNA chains
F4 input source, F6 purified hand-off
Short RNA chainsP2 · S3
wet-dry polymerisation of 2',3'-cyclic nucleotides (A, U, G, C) -> RNA oligomers
AUGC at pH 11: Y = 36%; 6% 4-mer, 0.1% 10-mer; G alone up to ~70% at pH 10
Yield only from purified inputs. Source
S4 · Template copying
Leads to or from a missing step
Template copyingP3 · S4
template-directed copying / ligation at pond pH
no published step known to us
No published step.
S5 · Sustained replication
Leads to or from a missing step
Sustained replicationP4 · S5
sustained replication
no published step known to us
No published step.
Ice and RNA
5 steps · 4 of 4 hand-offs unexplained
S1 · Small sugars
Not part of this route
S2 · Nucleotides
Raw materials of the setting
First break. F4 input source
Triplet building blocksI1 · S2
prebiotic synthesis of trinucleotide triphosphates (pppNNN)
no published step known to us
No published step.
S3 · RNA chains
Leads to or from a missing step
A 45-letter ribozymeI2 · S3
abiotic emergence of a 45-nt polymerase ribozyme (QT45)
no published step known to us
No published step.
S4 · Template copying
F4 input source, F6 purified hand-off
QT45 copies itselfI3 · S4
QT45 copies its complementary strand and itself from triplets in eutectic ice
(-) strand 0.24% and (+) strand 0.17% of template in 72 days; fidelity 94.1%/nt (64-triplet pool); 10.9% perfect full-length (-), 43.4% perfect (+) with defined triplets
Yield only from purified inputs. Source
F4 input source, F6 purified hand-off
Short RNAs multiplyI4 · S4
pH-freeze-thaw cycling: triplet-based exponential replication of short dsRNA by the TPR ribozyme
1.2-1.46-fold per cycle for short (+8 to +14 nt) products; 29-nt ribozyme fragment up to 1.26-fold per cycle; A_D duplex 9x (+) and 31x (-) over 21 cycles
Yield only from purified inputs. Source
S5 · Sustained replication
Leads to or from a missing step
Sustained replicationI5 · S5
exponential replication of a whole polymerase ribozyme by itself
no published step known to us
No published step.