Open Citizen ScienceOpen Mind

News

New papers and data in the field, newest first, and what we do with each. Every item opens at three levels of detail. RSS

Latest

2026-07-07 · Paper · Neuroscience of Consciousness 2026(1), niag029

A data-driven approach to identifying and evaluating connectivity-based neural correlates of conscious visual perception

Testing 246 ways of measuring brain connectivity on the COGITATE data gives tentative support to the workspace theory.

What we do with it: A second independent reanalysis of the same data, from a different angle. Its 246-measure sweep is a template for our pre-registered multiverse; we would hash the measure list first. Planned

2026-06 · Paper · Trends in Cognitive Sciences 30(6), 488-501

Identifying indicators of consciousness in AI systems

A method for judging whether an AI could be conscious by checking its inner workings against what theories of consciousness require, not by what it says.

What we do with it: The rubric for our AI stress tests: we use it to find where theories disagree or give absurd answers, never as a verdict on AI and never scoring an AI's self-report. Planned

2026-05-14 · Paper · Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews 187, 106742

Integrated information and predictive processing theories of consciousness: an adversarial collaborative review (INTREPID)

The second big adversarial collaboration has published its plan: IIT against two predictive-brain theories. No results yet.

What we do with it: If its data appears after we seal our predictions, it is a clean prospective test. Its evidence-pooling idea is a model for our own log-score comparison of theories. Planned

2026-02-14 · Paper · Translational Psychiatry 16, 160

Electrophysiological effects of psilocybin co-administered with midazolam

With a sedative given alongside psilocybin, brain-signal complexity still rose as the psychedelic effects came on.

What we do with it: A case where complexity and the spectral exponent move together under a drug that changes experience. Our test asks whether complexity adds anything once the exponent is known. Planned

2026-01-28 · Paper · Nature Human Behaviour 10, 777-802

Convergent transcriptomic and connectomic controllers of information integration and its anaesthetic breakdown across mammalian brains

Across humans, monkeys, marmosets and mice, anaesthetics break down the brain's integration of information, and waking a monkey with deep-brain stimulation brings it back.

What we do with it: Shows that whether a Phi-like proxy rises or falls under anaesthesia depends on the modality and the estimator. Our known-Phi network test (task #9) must check each proxy before we trust its direction. Planned

2025-09-24 · Paper + dataset · Scientific Reports (data: OpenNeuro ds005620)

A repeated awakening study exploring the capacity of complexity measures to capture dreaming during propofol sedation

Brain complexity dropped under sedation, but did not differ between people who said they had been dreaming and people who said they had not.

What we do with it: One of our L2 datasets. The full set is far over our 1.5 GB budget; we fetch only the pre-awakening sedation files per subject. The 5 no-experience awakenings make it weak alone for dream vs no-dream; pool with DREAM. Planned

2025-09-16 · Paper · Cerebral Cortex 35(9), bhaf254

The role of etiology in the identification of clinical markers of consciousness: comparing EEG alpha power, complexity, and spectral exponent

In 303 unresponsive patients, a popular complexity measure mostly repeated what the slope of the EEG spectrum already showed; once corrected for that, its diagnostic value vanished.

What we do with it: The direct source for our surrogate gate (task #8) and the LZ vs slope test (task #4). It is the PMC12448740 paper the plan cites. We also stratify by aetiology wherever patient data allow. Planned

2025-08-13 · Dataset · Nature Communications 16, 7495

A dream EEG and mentation database (DREAM)

Twenty sleep studies pooled their brain recordings with what people said they were dreaming when woken up: 505 people, 2,643 awakenings.

What we do with it: The key resource for our dream vs no-dream test (task #6). Their AUCs are the bar to beat, but we split by subject and lab, so our numbers may come out lower. Planned

2025-04-30 · Paper · Nature 642, 133-142

Adversarial testing of global neuronal workspace and integrated information theories of consciousness

The first big head-to-head test of two theories of consciousness found that each got some predictions right and each got key claims wrong.

What we do with it: The data is public (Experiment 1: MEG, fMRI, iEEG), so it is the first place we test whether the published conclusions survive other reasonable analyses. Note the paper's iEEG n is 34; the plan said 38. Planned

Landmarks

Older papers that set the terms of the question.

2024-08-05 · Paper · Communications Biology 7, 946

Critical dynamics in spontaneous EEG predict anesthetic-induced loss of consciousness and perturbational complexity

In 15 healthy adults under three anaesthetics, resting EEG predicted the stimulation-based consciousness index closely.

What we do with it: If true, the best-validated measure could be tested on many more open datasets. Caution: 15 subjects, 5 per drug, and the same cohort as Colombo 2019 and Sarasso 2015, so these are not independent replications. We test it out of sample. Planned

2023-09-16 · Letter · PsyArXiv (open letter); follow-up in Nature Neuroscience 28, 689-693 (2025)

The integrated information theory of consciousness as pseudoscience

A group of researchers called IIT pseudoscience, which set off a public dispute over what counts as a test of a theory of consciousness.

What we do with it: It is why we judge every theory only by predictions sealed in advance. Planned

2017-04-10 · Paper · Nature Neuroscience 20, 872-878

The neural correlates of dreaming

Less slow activity at the back of the brain marked dreaming in both kinds of sleep, and could predict a dream report in real time.

What we do with it: The sharpest within-stage test of a measure against report. The DREAM database (2025) lets us test whether it replicates across labs. Planned

2016-11-02 · Paper · Annals of Neurology 80, 718-729

Stratification of unresponsive patients by an independently validated index of brain complexity

A cutoff on the stimulation-based complexity index, set in people who could report, separated conscious from unconscious perfectly and flagged some 'vegetative' patients as possibly conscious.

What we do with it: The strongest published L2 result. No open TMS-EEG set of this kind exists, which is the biggest data gap in our plan. Planned

2015-11-19 · Paper · Current Biology 25, 3099-3105

Consciousness and complexity during unresponsiveness induced by propofol, xenon, and ketamine

Under ketamine, people stopped responding but their brain's response to a magnetic pulse stayed wake-like, and afterwards they reported vivid dreams.

What we do with it: Defines our ketamine dissociation case. The same group's data underlies Colombo 2019 and Maschke 2024, so we need an independent ketamine dataset. Planned